Amtul H
- Flag inappropriate
- Show review history
I love how detailed the story is. The author describes everything so beautifully that you can see the whole image in your head and it makes you question yourself. It is easy to give an answer when you are simply reading a story but when you actually come face-to-face with the situation, you are not able to make a decision easily or might decide on the opposite what you are thinking now. As the author said, the book is simply a question, the answer is what the readers come up with and I am thinking of that.
Najwa Salsabila Azmi
I read this book based on a recommendation of a boy band's leader in which they used this book as the inspiration for their song. I read this book with a clump in my chest, knowing the condition of the child. In the song, Spring Day by BTS, it is more like a continuation of what they can do to help the child - it was presented in the music video as a pair of unwanted shoes which tied up on the branches of a tree, longing for its freedom. It was a brilliant combination, it gives you more feels with the song
138 people found this review helpful
Keith Blackshear
This short story was my first time reading Ursula LeGuin. The story begins with an eloquent depiction of this ideal little town preparing for a festival. Everything seems perfect, yet there is mention of imperfections, but they are depicted as minor and not having serious negative consequence. The juxtaposition of this pristine society created by LeGuin to its deep, dark, hidden secret is a clear parallel to humanity's natural tendency to establish a sense of superiority at the expense of another person or group. LeGuin had no spefici injustice for her story, which is part of its beauty. This story can be applied to a wide ovarievariety of situations with which we are all familiar. With a lot of the tensions going on right now relating to race/gender/sexuality/politics/nationality, this short story felt particularly poignant.
1 person found this review helpful