Jacqueline
- Flag inappropriate
- Show review history
I wish I could could agree with some of the reviewers about this book, but I can't. the story is quite simple and straightforward, 1st the oppression which leads to, 2nd, the struggle and rebellion, and finally the push to create a better world for yourself. Not much actually happens in this book, but the author finds a way to drag it out with a lot of unnecessary overwriting. I know some find the writing poetic but I found it stilted, difficult to read and uninteresting. It did not keep my attention and I found myself scanning paragraphs at a time because they were long, drawn-out descriptions of Landscapes, scenery and the tedious inner monologue and angst that the characters go through. the characters were bland and boring and the end, while thorough and a fully thought-out story, left me unfulfilled and disappointed. The ending gives you no pay off whatsoever.
William Po
Agree with under-rated. Loved description of alien planet and life there. Wouldn't mind going into Space to get to someplace like that instead of some dead world in Earth's solar system. These sci-fi books were written before we could image other worlds, understood the uniqueness of Earth's biochemistry or understand the evolutionary history of life, or intelligence. It doesn't look like any world like Victoria is out there - even life bearing worlds would be more alien than this. Good story about people.
Bryan Stone
One of her best, and most underrated, books.
1 person found this review helpful