Red Flags in Psychotherapy: Stories of Ethics Complaints and Resolutions

Patricia Keith-Spiegel

Oct 2013 · Routledge

About this ebook

This book delves into risks that can easily bedevil any psychotherapist and what can happen if they are ignored. Dramatic storytelling, based on actual incidents from the author’s experiences as a member of ethics committees and as an ethics teacher and consultant, explores actions prompting clients to issue formal complaints. Set in the context of an ethics committee meeting over the course of a weekend, twelve psychologists face their peers who will stand in judgment. Issues include the fallout from losing one’s temper with a difficult client, a personal disclosure gone terribly wrong, a bartering arrangement that literally falls apart, a private life revealed in a most public way, a vengeful act that sullies the reputation of an entire department, breaking confidentiality when a client threatened harm, and the slippery slope to sexual exploitation.

The stories are absorbing, enlightening, sometimes shocking, and often stranger than fiction. Narrative nonfiction puts human faces and emotions on what would otherwise be cursory statistics. What led to the formal complaint from both the vantage point of the complainant and the psychologist offers insights not otherwise available unless the dynamics of their private lives leading up to the conflict are revealed. An author’s commentary and discussion questions follow every story. Both new and seasoned practitioners, as well as those still in training, will find this to be an invaluable resource.

Ratings and reviews

This is a great handbook for any professional engaged in psychotherapy and a useful tool for any client of a therapist or anyone contemplating going into therapy with a psychologist, psychiatrist or marriage and family counselor. This is an instructive book as it examines a sample of cases in which patients/clients have been dissatisfied with their therapist to the point they filed complaints with an ethics committee requesting redress or sanctions against the therapist. It is instructive as well as to how an ethics committee works to decide cases which is no easy job. This is a fun book and makes for exciting reading as the author is a great story teller casting both the therapist and the client in colorful descriptions such as you might find in a novel. The reader is given the chance to see how challenging some clients can be to any therapist, how well- or ill-prepared some therapists are for meeting the needs of clients, and from the standpoint of a committee, what they might have done to avoid having a therapeutic relationship deteriorate to the point where the client complains. The book has many tips for therapists and contains many helpful references, discussion question

About the author

Patricia Keith-Spiegel, PhD, is the Voran Honors Distinguished Professor of Social and Behavioral Sciences Emerita at Ball State University, where she was the director of the Center for Teaching Integrity. She was a member of the Ethics Committee of the California State Psychological Association and was also on the Ethics Committee of the American Psychological Association for six years, serving two terms as Chair.