Trent Kennedy
- Flag inappropriate
- Show review history
Alright, before y'all start ,.i know I'm a guy, but the books are good, ravenpaw is one of my favorites, but in this book, i feel like the author was kinda getting romantic, i mean, in all the other books, barley and ravenpaw we're friends who acted like brothers, and i was like"This is normal, and that's good" i mean, obviously without barley, ravenpaw would have died sooner, but in this book, it kinda feels like they're gay, and no offense, but all the other cats would act the same way to their mates, their lovers, so hyprthetically, ravenpaw and barely are gay, and so, before anyone starts arguing, do the research, and u'll understand, the book was good, jus kinda weird if u call the lovie dovie stuff friendship only, so I'm not saying don't read it, jus be kinda careful, all the other books are five star tho, so good job Hunter...
Clara Tidwell
Oh my goodness! I LOVED this book! It's just amazing! Ravenpaw was my favorite character since Book 1, and I hate to see him go, but I love this book! It was about time Ravenpaw got his own book. I've never cried reading a book before, but when Ravenpaw went to StarClan, I actually cried. This book is also very compelling. Great job, Erin Hunter!
1 person found this review helpful
Kikat
I honestly think that ravenpaw should get resurrected as ravenwing or ravenfeather. I also think that ashfur should be in the dark forest. Swiftpaw should also be resurrected. As a reference to some of my friends and I, could you name some characters Redscar, Silvermist, and Ravenfeather all in thunderclan or skyclan. Last thing, could you make a 6 part book series on skyclan. Thanks
8 people found this review helpful